|
|
Maddie Deutsch, MD 417 S. Hill St #201 Los Angeles, CA 90013 office
323.219.2469 fax 323.679.0389
Maddie@DoctorMaddie.com

|
|

Harm reduction
– This is a philosophy that accepts certain behaviors or conditions and attempts to encourage the safest courses
of action that still allow these behaviors or conditions to exist. For example, while there are (minimal)
risks associated with cross-gender hormone therapy, there are often greater risks when this therapy is withheld, such
as severe emotional distress. Some patients may turn to less than safe avenues such as self-management
via an overseas mail order pharmacy. The safest, most harm-reducing method is to accept that transgendered
patients at times require hormone therapy and provide these patients with proper medical supervision. Another
example might be someone who enjoys multiple body piercings. Some physicians may simply make judgment
on the patient’s lifestyle and tell them not to pierce. This leads to emotional upset and feelings
of invalidation. The patient will probably continue to pierce but may feel uneasy
about seeing their doctor should a complication arise. Harm reduction argues that if the physician
understands and accepts this behavior and then agrees to help guide the patient, the patient will be much healthier
(and happier!)
Dispelling myths about transgender care
- Many physicians are uncomfortable managing transgender patients for a number of reasons. There has
been alot of concern about issues such as blood clots, strokes, or effects on organs such as the liver or cholesterol
levels. Many of these concerns are either overblown or not based in evidence. For example, the well-known
(and flawed) Women's Health Initiative Study showed that women on post-menopausal hormone therapy have a 50% increased risk of stroke over those who do not. But if you look closely at the numbers, 32 out of 10,000 women
without hormones had strokes, and 48 women with hormones had strokes. So while there is a 50% increased risk,
your risk goes from .032% to .048%, which is still a remarkably low number and really should not persuade anyone to
avoid hormone therapy.
Another argument is the effect of testosterone therapy on cholesterol levels. It is
entirely likely that long term testosterone therapy will cause an increased risk of heart disease, stroke, and therefore
possibly even a shorter life span. In other words, it makes your overall risk profile just like that of a genetic male. Just as an unfortunate consequence of being a woman is that you are exposed to concerns such as
violence or descrimination, an unfortunate consequence of being a man is that you have a higher risk of heart disease
and a slightly shorter average lifespan. No one would ever deny a male to female transition based on an increased
risk of violence, so why deny a female to male transition, if (after informed consent) the individual agrees to accept
this risk profile in exchange for acheiving their true gender identity?
Self-directed care
– In the old days, doctors told patients what to do and the patients listened. In the modern,
internet-enabled era patients are often well-informed and at times more informed than their physicians on some topics.
Often there is more than one way to approach a medical problem. Patients may have questions
and deserve to have them answered in a non-judgmental way. Some patients may want to hear
about alternative or non-western treatment options. Others may want to hear the pros and cons of
several different approaches and make decisions for themselves or after discussion with friends or family, or perhaps
conduct their own research. I can even help teach you how to do this research on your own. Still
other patients may say, “Well Dr. Maddie, I just don’t know – you decide for me”. Nutrition, lifestyle and
preventive health – Americans are getting less and less healthy. Allergies and infections are up, energy
and activity levels are down. Without being judgmental or dictatorial, I’d like to help my patients
understand the links between overall health, nutrition, the glycemic index, diabetes, activity level, vitamins, weight
and emotional well being. While living a life based around organic produce and daily exercise is
not for everyone, you’d be amazed at some little things you can do to make big differences in your life.
Transgender care –
I believe that transgendered patients on hormone therapy should have a solid understanding of what they can
expect and knowledge about the various treatments they are receiving. They should understand the pros and cons of issues
such as cycling, the use of progesterone or Androcur, oral vs. injectable vs. transdermal medication as well as the
risks (and benefits) of hormone therapy in both the short and long term. Furthermore, transgender
medical care does not end with hormone prescriptions. Preventive care, focus on diet and weight management,
cholesterol, preventive health and screening, as well as holistic and emotional wellness and all other health issues
that are relevant to non-transgendered people are all cornerstones of a successful comprehensive care plan, FTM
or MTF.
The "De-medicalization" and "De-profitization"
of cross gender hormone therapy - Some physicians require that patients return for weekly injections, and charge
a fee for each visit. Some physicians refuse to prescribe hormones or even disclose to their patients exactly what hormones are being administered. Transgender care has become big business. No one should profit unfairly from the treatment of transgendered people or anyone else for that matter. I constantly wonder, "Why is transgender
care so 'medicalized'?" Diabetics inject themselves several times a day with insulin, frequently adjusting
the dose on their own after becoming educated about their condition. Without insulin, some diabetics could literally
die within days. My own grandmother gives herself weekly Epogen shots for her severe anemia. So it
is puzzling as to why a healthy, young transperson can not be educated about their therapy and inject themselves, only
coming to the office for periodic checkups and adjustments as needed.
Preserving the reproductive
future of transgendered patients - I firmly believe that prior to beginning cross gender hormone therapy, all
patients should receive counseling regarding therapy's effects on their reproductive future, and steps that can be
taken to preserve that future. Typically this involves cryopreservation (sperm or egg banking). I will discuss these matters with you prior to beginning your therapy so that you may make informed decisions about your
reproductive future.
The WPATH/HBIGDA Transgender Standards of Care - These
are guidelines. They are well written, relevant and in many cases appropriate. However,
as with everything else in life, nothing is cut and dry. I subscribe to the Standards of Care and
respect their importance. That said I am comfortable deviating from the standards of care if circumstances
support doing so.
|